Unofficial File parts/47311.dat
Warning: Model breaking changes to unofficial parts may occur anytime prior to release
0 Constraction Limb 5 Lower Section with 2 Ball Joints and Pinhole
0 Name: 47311.dat
0 Author: Max Murtazin [SwampKryakwa]
0 !LDRAW_ORG Unofficial_Part
0 !LICENSE Licensed under CC BY 4.0 : see CAreadme.txt
0 BFC CERTIFY CCW
0 !CATEGORY Constraction
0 !KEYWORDS arm, bionicle, forearm, Metru, Toa
0 !HISTORY 2021-02-20 [Lehvak_Nuva] Original part geometry
0 !HISTORY 2022-03-17 [SwampKryakwa] Part preparation for the part trackerShow file code:
1 16 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 s\47311s01.dat
1 16 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 s\47311s01.dat
5 24 0 15 .9 0 15.0768 -.5674 2.2961 14.6253 -.5369 -2.2961 14.6253 -.5369
5 24 0 15.0768 -.5674 0 14.816 -3.1304 2.2961 14.386 -3.1132 -2.2961 14.386 -3.1132
5 24 0 13.9562 -6.4067 0 14.816 -3.1304 2.2961 14.386 -3.1132 -2.2961 14.386 -3.1132
5 24 0 12.1641 -10.178 0 12.903 -8.73 2.2961 11.7739 -9.9491 -2.2961 11.7739 -9.9491
5 24 0 10.5524 -11.8793 0 12.1641 -10.178 2.2961 10.3051 -11.7578 -2.2961 10.3051 -11.7578
5 24 0 10.5524 -11.8793 0 9.771 -12.606 2.2961 10.3051 -11.7578 -2.2961 10.3051 -11.7578
1 16 10 0 0 0 -20 0 -6.36 0 6.36 -6.36 0 -6.36 2-4cyli.dat
1 16 0 0 0 0 -1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 connhole.dat
1 16 0 0 -40 12.81 0 0 0 12.81 0 0 0 12.81 8-8sphe.dat
1 16 0 0 -20 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 -7.2 0 axlehol8.dat
1 16 0 0 -40 0 0 1 -1 0 0 0 -1 0 axlesphe.dat
1 16 0 0 -20 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 axlehol9.dat
1 16 0 0 -20 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 axlehol2.dat
1 16 0 0 40 12.81 0 0 0 12.81 0 0 0 12.81 8-8sphe.dat
1 16 0 0 20 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 7.2 0 axlehol8.dat
1 16 0 0 40 0 0 1 -1 0 0 0 1 0 axlesphe.dat
1 16 0 0 20 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 axlehol2.dat
1 16 0 0 20 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 axlehol9.dat
1 16 0 9 7.9 6 0 0 0 0 6 0 -3.3 0 2-4cyli.dat
1 16 0 9 15.9 6 0 0 0 0 6 0 -3.3 0 2-4cyli.dat
1 16 0 -19.304 3.174 2.456 0 0 0 4.444 2.386 0 -18.216 .582 4-4cyli.dat
1 16 0 -19.304 3.174 2.456 0 0 0 1 2.386 0 0 .582 4-4edge.dat
1 16 0 -19.304 3.174 3.44 0 0 0 -.6995 3.342 0 2.86462 .815 4-4cylc3.dat
1 16 0 -19.304 3.174 3.44 0 0 0 1 3.342 0 0 .815 4-4edge.dat
1 16 0 -20.004 6.0386 0 0 3.44 3.342 -1.792 0 .815 7.395 0 4-4cylse.dat
1 16 0 9 20 9 0 0 0 0 9 0 -1 0 2-4disc.dat
1 16 0 9 20 9 0 0 0 0 9 0 -2.9 0 2-4cyli.dat
1 16 0 9 20 9 0 0 0 0 9 0 -1 0 2-4edge.dat
1 16 0 9 15.9 9 0 0 0 0 9 0 1 1.2 2-4edge.dat
1 16 0 9 15.9 3 0 0 0 0 3 0 1 .4 2-4ring2.dat
1 16 0 9 15.9 6 0 0 0 0 6 0 1 .8 2-4edge.dat
1 16 0 9 7.9 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 s\47311s02.dat
1 16 0 9 -.1 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 s\47311s02.dat
1 16 0 7.044 -7.098 1 0 0 0 .906 .423 0 -.423 .906 s\47311s02.dat
1 16 0 6.11904 -8.33407 3 0 0 0 -1 1.17076 0 0 -2.77787 2-4ring2.dat
1 16 0 6.11904 -8.33407 9 0 0 0 -1 3.51227 0 0 -8.33361 2-4edge.dat
1 16 0 6.11904 -8.33407 6 0 0 0 -1 2.34151 0 0 -5.55574 2-4edge.dat
1 16 0 6.11904 -8.33407 6 0 0 0 -1 2.34151 0 0 -5.55574 2-4ering.dat
1 16 0 4.368 -9.3 9 0 0 0 .91721 4.34684 0 .50592 -7.88067 2-4cyli.dat
1 16 0 4.368 -9.3 9 0 0 0 1 4.34684 0 0 -7.88067 2-4edge.dat
4 16 10.0127 -9.568 -2.2374 3.0234 -28.9784 22.6391 -3.0234 -28.9784 22.6391 -10.0127 -9.568 -2.2374
4 16 7.9338 -6.3639 -6.3639 10.0127 -9.568 -2.2374 -10.0127 -9.568 -2.2374 -7.9338 -6.3639 -6.3639
4 16 8.6191 9.2795 -20 3.53924 -14.75977 -19.89606 -3.53924 -14.75977 -19.89606 -8.6191 9.2795 -20
4 16 8.897 9.6275 -18.8355 -8.897 9.6275 -18.8355 -9 4.368 -9.3 9 4.368 -9.3
4 16 9 9 20 -9 9 20 -9 -9.8434 20 9 -9.8434 20
2 24 -9 -9.8434 20 9 -9.8434 20
4 16 9 -9.8434 20 -9 -9.8434 20 -5.3759 -22.3512 29.3211 5.3759 -22.3512 29.3211
4 16 -7.9338 -6.3639 -6.3639 -4.30197 -16.1512 -13.00474 4.30197 -16.1512 -13.00474 7.9338 -6.3639 -6.3639
4 16 -3.0234 -28.9784 22.6391 3.0234 -28.9784 22.6391 2.7513 -29.7337 23.6491 -2.7513 -29.7337 23.6491
4 16 -2.7513 -29.7337 23.6491 2.7513 -29.7337 23.6491 2.5819 -30.2008 24.7851 -2.5819 -30.2008 24.7851
4 16 2.5223 -30.3599 26.0031 -2.5223 -30.3599 26.0031 -2.5819 -30.2008 24.7851 2.5819 -30.2008 24.7851
4 16 -2.5223 -30.3599 26.0031 2.5223 -30.3599 26.0031 2.577 -30.1994 27.2211 -2.577 -30.1994 27.2211
4 16 2.577 -30.1994 27.2211 2.7418 -29.7307 28.3571 -2.7418 -29.7307 28.3571 -2.577 -30.1994 27.2211
4 16 2.7418 -29.7307 28.3571 3.0061 -28.9849 29.3321 -3.0061 -28.9849 29.3321 -2.7418 -29.7307 28.3571
4 16 3.0061 -28.9849 29.3321 3.3522 -28.0114 30.0801 -3.3522 -28.0114 30.0801 -3.0061 -28.9849 29.3321
4 16 3.3522 -28.0114 30.0801 3.7558 -26.8786 30.5501 -3.7558 -26.8786 30.5501 -3.3522 -28.0114 30.0801
4 16 3.7558 -26.8786 30.5501 4.1897 -25.6629 30.7111 -4.1897 -25.6629 30.7111 -3.7558 -26.8786 30.5501
4 16 4.1897 -25.6629 30.7111 4.6253 -24.4446 30.5501 -4.6253 -24.4446 30.5501 -4.1897 -25.6629 30.7111
4 16 5.3759 -22.3512 29.3211 -5.3759 -22.3512 29.3211 -5.0306 -23.313 30.0802 5.0306 -23.313 30.0802
4 16 4.6253 -24.4446 30.5501 5.0306 -23.313 30.0802 -5.0306 -23.313 30.0802 -4.6253 -24.4446 30.5501
5 24 10.0127 -9.568 -2.2374 -10.0127 -9.568 -2.2374 3.0234 -28.9784 22.6391 -7.9338 -6.3639 -6.3639
5 24 3.0234 -28.9784 22.6391 -3.0234 -28.9784 22.6391 2.7513 -29.7337 23.6491 -10.0127 -9.568 -2.2374
5 24 2.7513 -29.7337 23.6491 -2.7513 -29.7337 23.6491 -3.0234 -28.9784 22.6391 2.5819 -30.2008 24.7851
5 24 -2.5819 -30.2008 24.7851 2.5819 -30.2008 24.7851 2.5223 -30.3599 26.0031 -2.7513 -29.7337 23.6491
5 24 -3.7558 -26.8786 30.5501 3.7558 -26.8786 30.5501 -3.3522 -28.0114 30.0801 4.1897 -25.6629 30.7111
5 24 -3.0061 -28.9849 29.3321 3.0061 -28.9849 29.3321 -2.7418 -29.7307 28.3571 3.3522 -28.0114 30.0801
5 24 -4.6253 -24.4446 30.5501 4.6253 -24.4446 30.5501 -4.1897 -25.6629 30.7111 5.0306 -23.313 30.0802
5 24 -2.5223 -30.3599 26.0031 2.5223 -30.3599 26.0031 2.577 -30.1994 27.2211 -2.5819 -30.2008 24.7851
5 24 2.7418 -29.7307 28.3571 -2.7418 -29.7307 28.3571 3.0061 -28.9849 29.3321 -2.577 -30.1994 27.2211
5 24 -3.3522 -28.0114 30.0801 3.3522 -28.0114 30.0801 -3.0061 -28.9849 29.3321 3.7558 -26.8786 30.5501
5 24 4.1897 -25.6629 30.7111 -4.1897 -25.6629 30.7111 4.6253 -24.4446 30.5501 -3.7558 -26.8786 30.5501
5 24 -5.3759 -22.3512 29.3211 5.3759 -22.3512 29.3211 -5.0306 -23.313 30.0802 9 -9.8434 20
5 24 5.0306 -23.313 30.0802 -5.0306 -23.313 30.0802 -4.6253 -24.4446 30.5501 5.3759 -22.3512 29.3211
5 24 -2.577 -30.1994 27.2211 2.577 -30.1994 27.2211 2.7418 -29.7307 28.3571 -2.5223 -30.3599 26.0031
2 24 7.9338 -6.3639 -6.3639 -7.9338 -6.3639 -6.3639
5 24 3.53924 -14.75977 -19.89606 -3.53924 -14.75977 -19.89606 5.38661 -16.1512 -19.62726 8.6191 9.2795 -20
5 24 4.30197 -16.1512 -13.00474 -4.30197 -16.1512 -13.00474 -7.9338 -6.3639 -6.3639 -5.38661 -17.31385 -13.78175
2 24 -2.2691 -14.63978 -11.97907 -2.456 -15.46984 -12.54227
2 24 -2.456 -15.46984 -12.54227 -2.29868 -16.16853 -13.01633
2 24 0 -13.30088 -11.07063 -.93991 -13.46593 -11.18262
2 24 -.93991 -13.46593 -11.18262 -1.73664 -13.93617 -11.50167
2 24 -2.2691 -14.63978 -11.97907 -1.73664 -13.93617 -11.50167
4 16 -8.897 9.6275 -18.8355 8.897 9.6275 -18.8355 8.6191 9.2795 -20 -8.6191 9.2795 -20
2 24 -8.6191 9.2795 -20 8.6191 9.2795 -20
2 24 8.897 9.6275 -18.8355 -8.897 9.6275 -18.8355Status
Errors Found (HN)
Current Votes:
Max Murtazin [SwampKryakwa]
This part has the following automated holds from the Parts Tracker
-
Has Uncertified Subfiles
Part Dependencies
Official parents and subparts
Part Events
Max Murtazin [SwampKryakwa]
initially submitted the part.
2022-03-17 15:55:02
Magnus Forsberg [MagFors]
posted a vote of Hold
2022-03-17 17:30:01
Gerald Lasser [GeraldLasser]
made the following comment.
2022-03-17 21:15:01
I put some feedback in the forum, have a look here:
https://forums.ldraw.org/thread-26124-post-45360.html#pid45360
https://forums.ldraw.org/thread-26124-post-45360.html#pid45360
Max Murtazin [SwampKryakwa]
submitted a new version of the part (all votes reset).
2022-03-18 15:35:01
Added conditional lines, fixed outlines and geometry, replace of some elements with primitives, replaced axle primitive with set of proper ones
Existing certification-votes were deleted.
Existing certification-votes were deleted.
Max Murtazin [SwampKryakwa]
submitted a new version of the part (all votes reset).
2022-03-18 15:40:01
Restored accidentally removed cylinder
Willy Tschager [Holly-Wood]
posted a vote of Hold
2022-03-30 13:25:02
* Rounding
* Quads near coplanarity
* Coplanar quads
* Invalid use of upper & mixed case in subfile name
* Flat subfile scaled in y direction
* Invalid us of BFC INVERTNEXT on flat subfiles
* Missing edges (example)
2 4 3.205632 -28.548836 23.124964 3.003786 -29.135415 24.002667
2 4 3.003786 -29.135415 24.002667 2.901834 -29.431316 24.445427
2 4 3.21498 -28.523798 23.10823 3.557525 -27.390524 22.350851
* However it would be better if you eliminate these:
3 1 4.2115 -25.6706 26.0032 2.7904 -29.7476 23.6492 3.0515 -28.9896 22.6392
3 1 4.2115 -25.6706 26.0032 2.6293 -30.2176 24.7852 2.7904 -29.7476 23.6492
building a proper surface:
4 27 2.902 -29.431 24.445 2.629 -30.218 24.785 2.79 -29.748 23.649 3.215 -28.524 23.108
4 27 3.215 -28.524 23.108 2.79 -29.748 23.649 3.052 -28.99 22.639 3.61 -27.228 22.242
* The part is already slip in half:
4 73 3.0515 -28.9896 22.6392 0 -28.9896 22.6392 0 -9.5717 -2.2374 10 -9.5717 -2.2374
4 73 -3.0515 -28.9896 22.6392 -10 -9.5717 -2.2374 0 -9.5717 -2.2374 0 -28.9896 22.6392
Why didn't you subfile?
* Quads near coplanarity
* Coplanar quads
* Invalid use of upper & mixed case in subfile name
* Flat subfile scaled in y direction
* Invalid us of BFC INVERTNEXT on flat subfiles
* Missing edges (example)
2 4 3.205632 -28.548836 23.124964 3.003786 -29.135415 24.002667
2 4 3.003786 -29.135415 24.002667 2.901834 -29.431316 24.445427
2 4 3.21498 -28.523798 23.10823 3.557525 -27.390524 22.350851
* However it would be better if you eliminate these:
3 1 4.2115 -25.6706 26.0032 2.7904 -29.7476 23.6492 3.0515 -28.9896 22.6392
3 1 4.2115 -25.6706 26.0032 2.6293 -30.2176 24.7852 2.7904 -29.7476 23.6492
building a proper surface:
4 27 2.902 -29.431 24.445 2.629 -30.218 24.785 2.79 -29.748 23.649 3.215 -28.524 23.108
4 27 3.215 -28.524 23.108 2.79 -29.748 23.649 3.052 -28.99 22.639 3.61 -27.228 22.242
* The part is already slip in half:
4 73 3.0515 -28.9896 22.6392 0 -28.9896 22.6392 0 -9.5717 -2.2374 10 -9.5717 -2.2374
4 73 -3.0515 -28.9896 22.6392 -10 -9.5717 -2.2374 0 -9.5717 -2.2374 0 -28.9896 22.6392
Why didn't you subfile?
Max Murtazin [SwampKryakwa]
submitted a new version of the part (all votes reset).
2022-04-01 15:05:01
Separated main geometry into the subpart, fixed quad coplanarity, flat subfile Y scaling, use of BFC INVERTNEXT on flat subfiles, added missing edgelines
Existing certification-votes were deleted.
Existing certification-votes were deleted.
Max Murtazin [SwampKryakwa]
submitted a new version of the part (all votes reset).
2022-04-01 15:05:01
Removal of accidentally left unnecessary cylinder
Magnus Forsberg [MagFors]
made the following comment.
2022-04-01 15:30:01
I see no reason to have all these history comments.
Please delete them, but do please tell us what you have changed when you upload a new version.
I think you could use the same comment type as we use when we prepare ldd data.
Something like this:
0 !HISTORY 2013-08-14 [SwampKryakwa] Original part shape by Lehvak Nuva
0 !HISTORY 2018-07-22 [SwampKryakwa] File preparation for LDraw Parts Tracker with consent of oiginal author
Any comment on this, Orion?
Please delete them, but do please tell us what you have changed when you upload a new version.
I think you could use the same comment type as we use when we prepare ldd data.
Something like this:
0 !HISTORY 2013-08-14 [SwampKryakwa] Original part shape by Lehvak Nuva
0 !HISTORY 2018-07-22 [SwampKryakwa] File preparation for LDraw Parts Tracker with consent of oiginal author
Any comment on this, Orion?
Orion Pobursky [OrionP]
made the following comment.
2022-04-01 16:00:01
Just to pile onto Magnus's comment:
This is a new part authored by you. You don't have to add a history line every time you make an edit. History lines should be made if:
- You are not the part author -or-
- You update an official part and have it resubmitted to the tracker
And multiple sequential line by the same person can be combined into one. The most important reason for history is to document who has changed a file.
This is a new part authored by you. You don't have to add a history line every time you make an edit. History lines should be made if:
- You are not the part author -or-
- You update an official part and have it resubmitted to the tracker
And multiple sequential line by the same person can be combined into one. The most important reason for history is to document who has changed a file.
Max Murtazin [SwampKryakwa]
made the following comment.
2022-04-02 18:00:01
Okay, I understand now. Should I re-upload file without history lines mentioning various edits then?
Willy Tschager [Holly-Wood]
posted a vote of Hold
2022-04-06 20:35:01
* Missing intersections:
1 4 -5.38661 -14.7796 -16.316 0 5.38612 0 3.684 0 0 0 0 3.684 4-4cylc3.dat
1 4 0 -19.3036 3.17418 1 0 0 0 .2368 .9715 0 -.9715 .2368 s\47311s01.dat
* What's the reason for s01?
* Should use a:
1 16 0 0 0 0 -1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 connhole.dat
instead of pegholes+cyli
* Lots of blanks between the figures
* IMHO the half cylinders:
1 16 5.38661 -14.7796 -16.316 0 -5.38612 0 3.684 0 0 0 0 3.684 4-4cylc3.dat
1 4 -5.38661 -14.7796 -16.316 0 5.38612 0 3.684 0 0 0 0 3.684 4-4cylc3.dat
should actually be a cylc covering the entire lenght + a disc
* HISTORY lines not needed as progress is documented in PT
1 4 -5.38661 -14.7796 -16.316 0 5.38612 0 3.684 0 0 0 0 3.684 4-4cylc3.dat
1 4 0 -19.3036 3.17418 1 0 0 0 .2368 .9715 0 -.9715 .2368 s\47311s01.dat
* What's the reason for s01?
* Should use a:
1 16 0 0 0 0 -1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 connhole.dat
instead of pegholes+cyli
* Lots of blanks between the figures
* IMHO the half cylinders:
1 16 5.38661 -14.7796 -16.316 0 -5.38612 0 3.684 0 0 0 0 3.684 4-4cylc3.dat
1 4 -5.38661 -14.7796 -16.316 0 5.38612 0 3.684 0 0 0 0 3.684 4-4cylc3.dat
should actually be a cylc covering the entire lenght + a disc
* HISTORY lines not needed as progress is documented in PT
Max Murtazin [SwampKryakwa]
submitted a new version of the part (all votes reset).
2022-04-16 15:05:01
Replaced primitives making up pinhole with a proper primitive, replaced outer arm cylinder with the half cylinder, renumerated pb04 as pb01, old pb01 is part of the main file now. Moved cylinders into main subfile
Existing certification-votes were deleted.
Existing certification-votes were deleted.
Max Murtazin [SwampKryakwa]
submitted a new version of the part (all votes reset).
2022-04-16 15:15:01
Fixed accidentally inversed cylinder
Willy Tschager [Holly-Wood]
posted a vote of Hold
2022-04-18 09:15:01
* Some rounding required:
1 16 .000000000000000000000000000000456 -20.038138168885785496384262605933 6.1846642000000460496861684733439 0 0 3.44 3.3419600000000511200853296593222 -1.7917345782153980282913915663261 0 .81541606459503746855617121608742 7.343374200000112327471217973513 0 4-4cylse.dat
* My suggestion for fixing this bleeding:
3 1 -4.2427 12.5135 -5.3614 -2.2961 13.5812 -6.135 -2.2961 14.386 -3.1132
4 4 -5.6098 7.8877 -9.3792 -5.5433 7.0972 -10.0157 -4.2427 8.0999 -11.7154 -4.2427 9.3476 -10.8554
would be copying the prim temporarily to s01 and merge the vertices to the prim.
* As you have to fix the edges in s01 anyway I would suggest that you merge first:
-9.5359 3.4745 -8.2949
to the edge of:
1 16 10 0 0 0 -20 0 -6.36 0 6.36 -6.36 0 -6.36 2-4cyli.dat
*
1 16 .000000000000000000000000000000456 -20.038138168885785496384262605933 6.1846642000000460496861684733439 0 0 3.44 3.3419600000000511200853296593222 -1.7917345782153980282913915663261 0 .81541606459503746855617121608742 7.343374200000112327471217973513 0 4-4cylse.dat
* My suggestion for fixing this bleeding:
3 1 -4.2427 12.5135 -5.3614 -2.2961 13.5812 -6.135 -2.2961 14.386 -3.1132
4 4 -5.6098 7.8877 -9.3792 -5.5433 7.0972 -10.0157 -4.2427 8.0999 -11.7154 -4.2427 9.3476 -10.8554
would be copying the prim temporarily to s01 and merge the vertices to the prim.
* As you have to fix the edges in s01 anyway I would suggest that you merge first:
-9.5359 3.4745 -8.2949
to the edge of:
1 16 10 0 0 0 -20 0 -6.36 0 6.36 -6.36 0 -6.36 2-4cyli.dat
*
Magnus Forsberg [MagFors]
posted a vote of Hold
2022-04-18 21:05:02
Dividing large flat surfaces into 2 halves, like these (and many more), is never a good idea:
4 12 8.6191 9.2795 -20 3.5191 -14.7796 -20 -3.5191 -14.7796 -20 -8.6191 9.2795 -20
4 12 -9.5359 3.4745 -8.2949 9.5359 3.4745 -8.2949 8.897 9.6275 -18.8355 -8.897 9.6275 -18.8355
4 12 -4.3072 -16.1891 -12.9123 4.3071 -16.1893 -12.9124 7.9338 -6.3639 -6.3639 -7.9338 -6.3639 -6.3639
4 12 10.0127 -9.568 -2.2374 -10.0127 -9.568 -2.2374 -10.0138 -6.3639 -6.3639 10 -6.3639 -6.3639
4 12 -3.0234 -28.9784 22.6391 3.0234 -28.9784 22.6391 2.7513 -29.7337 23.6491 -2.7513 -29.7337 23.6491
4 12 2.5819 -30.2008 24.7851 -2.5819 -30.2008 24.7851 -2.7513 -29.7337 23.6491 2.7513 -29.7337 23.6491
4 12 2.5819 -30.2008 24.7851 2.5223 -30.3599 26.0031 -2.5223 -30.3599 26.0031 -2.5819 -30.2008 24.7851
This one is never made in trans plastic. Right?
I don't understand the use of a ndis and a axleho10 at the base of one of the axles. This only adds triangles in the mesh that no one will ever see.
4 12 8.6191 9.2795 -20 3.5191 -14.7796 -20 -3.5191 -14.7796 -20 -8.6191 9.2795 -20
4 12 -9.5359 3.4745 -8.2949 9.5359 3.4745 -8.2949 8.897 9.6275 -18.8355 -8.897 9.6275 -18.8355
4 12 -4.3072 -16.1891 -12.9123 4.3071 -16.1893 -12.9124 7.9338 -6.3639 -6.3639 -7.9338 -6.3639 -6.3639
4 12 10.0127 -9.568 -2.2374 -10.0127 -9.568 -2.2374 -10.0138 -6.3639 -6.3639 10 -6.3639 -6.3639
4 12 -3.0234 -28.9784 22.6391 3.0234 -28.9784 22.6391 2.7513 -29.7337 23.6491 -2.7513 -29.7337 23.6491
4 12 2.5819 -30.2008 24.7851 -2.5819 -30.2008 24.7851 -2.7513 -29.7337 23.6491 2.7513 -29.7337 23.6491
4 12 2.5819 -30.2008 24.7851 2.5223 -30.3599 26.0031 -2.5223 -30.3599 26.0031 -2.5819 -30.2008 24.7851
This one is never made in trans plastic. Right?
I don't understand the use of a ndis and a axleho10 at the base of one of the axles. This only adds triangles in the mesh that no one will ever see.
Max Murtazin [SwampKryakwa]
made the following comment.
2022-04-20 21:15:01
Reason for using ndis and axleho10 is keeping geometry convex. Generally, non-convex geometry might be harmful to the renders. Some software, like Studio, also uses custom Hi-Res primitives for axles and some other stuff. I want to ensure that model wouldn't have problems with any LDraw-powered software, and because of that I also come to use such methods, despite that they might look like unnecessary additions.
As far as I'm aware LDraw standards doesn't restrict this, if I'm wrong I will rework part around axle, but I'd prefer it to be kept if possible
As far as I'm aware LDraw standards doesn't restrict this, if I'm wrong I will rework part around axle, but I'd prefer it to be kept if possible
Max Murtazin [SwampKryakwa]
submitted a new version of the part (all votes reset).
2022-07-10 20:50:01
Fixed geometry
Existing certification-votes were deleted.
Existing certification-votes were deleted.
Max Murtazin [SwampKryakwa]
submitted a new version of the part (all votes reset).
2022-07-12 10:45:02
Removed accidental use of s03
Max Murtazin [SwampKryakwa]
submitted a new version of the part (all votes reset).
2022-10-30 20:10:01
Precision fix
Max Murtazin [SwampKryakwa]
submitted a new version of the part (all votes reset).
2022-10-31 17:35:01
Precision fix
[PTadmin]
edited the part header.
2022-11-24 17:50:01
Magnus Forsberg [MagFors]
made the following comment.
2022-11-24 17:50:01
Added "Constraction" and removed "Towball"
Magnus Forsberg [MagFors]
posted a vote of Hold
2022-11-26 15:20:01
I still don't understand why flat surfaces are made from many tiny triangles, or divided in the subfiles.
4 5 8.6191 9.2795 -20 3.5191 -14.7796 -20 -3.5191 -14.7796 -20 -8.6191 9.2795 -20
4 5 -9.0017 -9.8434 20 9.0017 -9.8434 20 9 9 20 -9.0017 9 20
Adding this doesn't make the surface convex.
3 16 10.0127 -9.568 -2.2374 0 -6.3639 -6.3639 0 -6.3419 -6.3639
3 16 -10.0127 -9.568 -2.2374 0 -6.3639 -6.3639 0 -6.3419 -6.3639
The file contain some editing relicts from LDPE
Missing or misplaced edge lines
2 4 9 4.1675 -9.4766 9.0017 3.4437 -8.3163
2 4 9.0017 3.4437 -8.3163 9.5359 3.4745 -8.2949
2 4 5.6516 -21.6001 26.0032 5.531456 -21.926562 27.585929
2 4 5.531456 -21.926562 27.585929 5.2193 -22.7924 28.8814
Thin gaps or T-junctions here
2 4 9 9 20 9 9 15.9
2 4 9 9 12.6 9 9 7.9
2 4 9 9 4.6 9 9 0
2 4 9 9.0321 -2.8398 9 7.044 -7.098
2 4 9 4.1675 -9.4766 9 5.913 -8.011
This surface doesn't work well
3 11 2.7536 -11.6436 -14.1151 5.2319 -11.6659 -14.1344 5.0286 -11.0123 -15.9998
3 11 5.0286 -11.0123 -15.9998 2.7536 -11.0406 -16.0241 2.7536 -11.6436 -14.1151
4 12 .00051 -11.0956 -16.316 .00051 -11.3759524 -14.9061332 5.38661 -11.3759524 -14.9061332 5.38661 -11.0956 -16.316
4 12 .00051 -11.3759524 -14.9061332 .00051 -12.1746436 -13.7110436 5.38661 -12.1746436 -13.7110436 5.38661 -11.3759524 -14.9061332
..and yes, I know many of these are in the subfile.
4 5 8.6191 9.2795 -20 3.5191 -14.7796 -20 -3.5191 -14.7796 -20 -8.6191 9.2795 -20
4 5 -9.0017 -9.8434 20 9.0017 -9.8434 20 9 9 20 -9.0017 9 20
Adding this doesn't make the surface convex.
3 16 10.0127 -9.568 -2.2374 0 -6.3639 -6.3639 0 -6.3419 -6.3639
3 16 -10.0127 -9.568 -2.2374 0 -6.3639 -6.3639 0 -6.3419 -6.3639
The file contain some editing relicts from LDPE
Missing or misplaced edge lines
2 4 9 4.1675 -9.4766 9.0017 3.4437 -8.3163
2 4 9.0017 3.4437 -8.3163 9.5359 3.4745 -8.2949
2 4 5.6516 -21.6001 26.0032 5.531456 -21.926562 27.585929
2 4 5.531456 -21.926562 27.585929 5.2193 -22.7924 28.8814
Thin gaps or T-junctions here
2 4 9 9 20 9 9 15.9
2 4 9 9 12.6 9 9 7.9
2 4 9 9 4.6 9 9 0
2 4 9 9.0321 -2.8398 9 7.044 -7.098
2 4 9 4.1675 -9.4766 9 5.913 -8.011
This surface doesn't work well
3 11 2.7536 -11.6436 -14.1151 5.2319 -11.6659 -14.1344 5.0286 -11.0123 -15.9998
3 11 5.0286 -11.0123 -15.9998 2.7536 -11.0406 -16.0241 2.7536 -11.6436 -14.1151
4 12 .00051 -11.0956 -16.316 .00051 -11.3759524 -14.9061332 5.38661 -11.3759524 -14.9061332 5.38661 -11.0956 -16.316
4 12 .00051 -11.3759524 -14.9061332 .00051 -12.1746436 -13.7110436 5.38661 -12.1746436 -13.7110436 5.38661 -11.3759524 -14.9061332
..and yes, I know many of these are in the subfile.
Max Murtazin [SwampKryakwa]
submitted a new version of the part (all votes reset).
2022-11-30 18:10:01
Fix of mentioned issues
Existing certification-votes were deleted.
Existing certification-votes were deleted.
Max Murtazin [SwampKryakwa]
submitted a new version of the part (all votes reset).
2022-12-03 11:55:01
Fixed outlines, rounded
Max Murtazin [SwampKryakwa]
submitted a new version of the part (all votes reset).
2022-12-04 13:35:01
Improved part accuracy
Willy Tschager [Holly-Wood]
posted a vote of Hold
2022-12-06 18:10:01
* Missing edges:
2 14 -2.7536 -19.7325 24.7168 -2.7536 -2.313 10.698
2 14 2.7536 -19.7325 24.7168 2.7536 -2.313 10.698
2 2 -9 7.117 5.237 -10.0006 7.117 5.237
2 2 9 7.117 5.237 10.0006 7.117 5.237
* Superfluouse empty prims:
1 16 0 0 20 6 0 0 0 0 6 0 -1 0 1-16disc.dat
1 16 0 0 20 6 0 0 0 0 -6 0 -1 0 1-16chrd.dat
1 16 0 0 20 -6 0 0 0 0 6 0 -1 0 1-16chrd.dat
1 16 0 0 20 -6 0 0 0 0 -6 0 -1 0 1-16chrd.dat
1 16 0 0 20 0 0 6 6 0 0 0 -1 0 1-16chrd.dat
1 16 0 0 20 0 0 6 -6 0 0 0 -1 0 1-16chrd.dat
1 16 0 0 20 0 0 -6 6 0 0 0 -1 0 1-16chrd.dat
1 16 0 0 20 0 0 -6 -6 0 0 0 -1 0 1-16chrd.dat
2 14 -2.7536 -19.7325 24.7168 -2.7536 -2.313 10.698
2 14 2.7536 -19.7325 24.7168 2.7536 -2.313 10.698
2 2 -9 7.117 5.237 -10.0006 7.117 5.237
2 2 9 7.117 5.237 10.0006 7.117 5.237
* Superfluouse empty prims:
1 16 0 0 20 6 0 0 0 0 6 0 -1 0 1-16disc.dat
1 16 0 0 20 6 0 0 0 0 -6 0 -1 0 1-16chrd.dat
1 16 0 0 20 -6 0 0 0 0 6 0 -1 0 1-16chrd.dat
1 16 0 0 20 -6 0 0 0 0 -6 0 -1 0 1-16chrd.dat
1 16 0 0 20 0 0 6 6 0 0 0 -1 0 1-16chrd.dat
1 16 0 0 20 0 0 6 -6 0 0 0 -1 0 1-16chrd.dat
1 16 0 0 20 0 0 -6 6 0 0 0 -1 0 1-16chrd.dat
1 16 0 0 20 0 0 -6 -6 0 0 0 -1 0 1-16chrd.dat
Magnus Forsberg [MagFors]
posted a vote of Hold
2022-12-18 21:15:01
This is not needed, only adding duplicated surface.
1 16 0 6.11904 -8.33407 9 0 0 0 -1 3.51227 0 0 -8.33361 2-4ering.dat
1 16 0 6.11904 -8.33407 9 0 0 0 -1 3.51227 0 0 -8.33361 2-4ering.dat
Max Murtazin [SwampKryakwa]
submitted a new version of the part (all votes reset).
2022-12-26 20:10:01
Fixed issues, moved few prims to the subfile
Existing certification-votes were deleted.
Existing certification-votes were deleted.
Magnus Forsberg [MagFors]
made the following comment.
2022-12-27 14:45:01
I wonder,
Could you close the gap that comes when the prims in the s02-subfiles are in hi-res mode?
The bow between the s02-subfiles is still in normal resolution when the s02 is in hi-res.
There is already an 2-4ering in one of the problematic gaps
1 16 0 6.11904 -8.33407 6 0 0 0 -1 2.34151 0 0 -5.55574 2-4edge.dat
1 16 0 6.11904 -8.33407 6 0 0 0 -1 2.34151 0 0 -5.55574 2-4ering.dat
But I don't like the shape shifting 2-4edge prim..... Hm
It looks to me like the bow is part of a torus. Something like this shape?
1 12 0 0 0 0 -5 0 15.1 0 0 0 0 16.8 48/4-4cyli.dat
Could you close the gap that comes when the prims in the s02-subfiles are in hi-res mode?
The bow between the s02-subfiles is still in normal resolution when the s02 is in hi-res.
There is already an 2-4ering in one of the problematic gaps
1 16 0 6.11904 -8.33407 6 0 0 0 -1 2.34151 0 0 -5.55574 2-4edge.dat
1 16 0 6.11904 -8.33407 6 0 0 0 -1 2.34151 0 0 -5.55574 2-4ering.dat
But I don't like the shape shifting 2-4edge prim..... Hm
It looks to me like the bow is part of a torus. Something like this shape?
1 12 0 0 0 0 -5 0 15.1 0 0 0 0 16.8 48/4-4cyli.dat
Max Murtazin [SwampKryakwa]
made the following comment.
2022-12-27 16:25:01
Hi-res mode is definitely causing some problems. I will try replacing the toroidal sections with cylis and cylses, so far looks like the only fitting solution to me
Max Murtazin [SwampKryakwa]
made the following comment.
2022-12-27 16:30:01
Also, is there any preference for part being oriented like on official renders? Better be rotated 180 degrees along Y if that's the case: https://img.bricklink.com/ItemImage/PN/59/47311.png
Max Murtazin [SwampKryakwa]
posted a vote of Hold
2023-03-12 02:00:13
Holding it for myself - need to get bit more work done on this
Orion Pobursky [OrionP]
posted a vote of Hold
2023-05-24 01:45:44
Source of geometry hasn't agreed to CA.
Orion Pobursky [OrionP]
edited the part header.
2023-05-25 17:58:11
Update Lehvak_Nuva user name
Orion Pobursky [OrionP]
cancelled their vote.
2023-05-25 17:58:36
Lehvak_Nuva has now affirmed the CA
Orion Pobursky [OrionP]
edited the part header.
2023-05-25 18:02:46
Update to better credit Lehvak_Nuva
Magnus Forsberg [MagFors]
edited the part header.
2024-08-17 05:08:50
Header Edits
keywords:
arm, bionicle, forearm, Metru, Technic, Toa
to
arm, bionicle, forearm, Metru, Toa
Jeff Jones [notmaster]
made the following comment.
2024-11-02 09:02:22
i could rework it
Jeff Jones [notmaster]
made the following comment.
2025-04-03 13:14:15
looking at it, dont know what any problems there is to rework, it looks fine to me.
Jeff Jones [notmaster]
made the following comment.
2026-03-03 12:58:34
bĘŚmp
Jeff Jones [notmaster]
made the following comment.
2026-03-17 10:59:01
bump yet again
Missing all conditional edgelines
Missing edgelines on intersection surfaces
Using complete cylinder primitives where a semi cylinder would be enough.
Using a complete axle.dat primitive instead of appropriate axle primitives.
Trailing zero error.
Divided large surfaces across major-axis into left/right halves.
I strongly recommend that you study the Ldraw Standards documentation.